Reply to Confused_100
LeonhartAugust said:
Shounen fans are a immensely spoiled bunch; a lot of battle shounen have good adaptations with top tier animation and get seasons after seasons but even that isn't enough. You guys wouldn't survive being fans of several non battle shounen anime.
Shounen fans are a immensely spoiled bunch; a lot of battle shounen have good adaptations with top tier animation and get seasons after seasons but even that isn't enough. You guys wouldn't survive being fans of several non battle shounen anime.
Sure⊠Do you even watch those because they have better animation than this lol
| @Confused_100 Sure, it wasn't like that back then (Naruto had a lot of "quality" animation; Claymore, Magi, Soul Eater are incomplete adaptations, two of which have anime original endings; for example, Bleach having endless fillers, etc), but nowadays, battle shounen get good treatment. Bleach now has a high quality sequel, JJK despite MAPPA has great animation, and so does Demon Slayer (both get sequels announced shortly after the season ends); Same goes for Dandadan, Boku no Hero Academia and Fire Force. There are outliers for sure, but that's the standard treatment battle shounen get in the late 2010s and current decade. Also, One Piece has a remake in the making despite the source material still being incomplete. |
  |
Reply to Confused_100
ejleon said:
I agree 100%, this is a ridiculous complaint
FutoiOtaku said:
Many thousands of viewers are watching and enjoying this well above average anime. But one or two elitists arenât satisfied so it has to be scrapped? Just donât watch it if you donât like it! Do I have to buy the comics because you had it stopped? Or can I continue watching it in the media of my choice? Glad MAL members have absolutely no influence on the Japanese entertainment industryâŠ
Many thousands of viewers are watching and enjoying this well above average anime. But one or two elitists arenât satisfied so it has to be scrapped? Just donât watch it if you donât like it! Do I have to buy the comics because you had it stopped? Or can I continue watching it in the media of my choice? Glad MAL members have absolutely no influence on the Japanese entertainment industryâŠ
I agree 100%, this is a ridiculous complaint
Bruh really have no background that Japanese hate this huhâŠ
| @Confused_100 Do you always let everyone else decide for you what you should like or dislike? Honestly, I donât care if Iâm the only human on earth that lies a certain anime, if I enjoy, that is all that matters. |
Note: I donât lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.  |
Reply to Confused_100
ejleon said:
*delete forum post*
After reading, this post was not worth my time.
It is a person complaint and basically irrelevant.
Most âbad art / animationâ complaints are people that have no clue what they are talking about, and have nothing else that they can complain about, so they just attack âart / animationâ.
I wish people would stop doing this and stop making these pathetic posts.
It has been perfectly enjoyable as is, you people are just spoiled and unappreciative.
I grew up watching 1980s & 90s cartoons, two decades of cartoons you people would trash and mock, because âbad art / animationâ, without realizing that it is the good story and characters that actually matter.
*delete forum post*
After reading, this post was not worth my time.
It is a person complaint and basically irrelevant.
Most âbad art / animationâ complaints are people that have no clue what they are talking about, and have nothing else that they can complain about, so they just attack âart / animationâ.
I wish people would stop doing this and stop making these pathetic posts.
It has been perfectly enjoyable as is, you people are just spoiled and unappreciative.
I grew up watching 1980s & 90s cartoons, two decades of cartoons you people would trash and mock, because âbad art / animationâ, without realizing that it is the good story and characters that actually matter.
You comparing a 2020s to a 1990s animationâŠ. What kind of technology you think they are using for this adaptation? Lol
| @Confused_100 My point flew over your head. Iâm saying that animation today is far more advanced than it was, and people are spoiled, so they donât appreciate it. |
| Note: I donât lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Reply to Confused_100
GTRaijin said:
Tbh, CSM situation was absolutely stupid. I don't think they could have done a better adaptation than what it was already but for some reason most of the people who have watched it, shat on it for fuck knows why (majority was japanese audience in fact).
They were treating it like some pile of crap, how it was ruined, etc., when it was the complete opposite. Sure, the sales were kinda not that good considering the manga's popularity, but you can't deny that it was a high quality adaptation even if they took a different approach of animating and directing it.
Now with Sakamoto Days, to me, personally, it's in a weird spot of being slightly below good but still above average. With each new episode it gets a bit worse and I'm not sure if it's the way it's animated/directed or I'm just not really feeling the vibe of it. I don't want to criticize it more because these days for some reason, you can't say anything bad about basically any anime or you will be considered as a hater or whatever. You either have to enjoy/appreciate eveything or just don't watch anything at all.
Tedybeer said:
oh no, it's like the Chainsaw Man anime stupid discussion all over again đ€Łđ€Łđ€Ł At this point idk if this is just trolling.
oh no, it's like the Chainsaw Man anime stupid discussion all over again đ€Łđ€Łđ€Ł At this point idk if this is just trolling.
Tbh, CSM situation was absolutely stupid. I don't think they could have done a better adaptation than what it was already but for some reason most of the people who have watched it, shat on it for fuck knows why (majority was japanese audience in fact).
They were treating it like some pile of crap, how it was ruined, etc., when it was the complete opposite. Sure, the sales were kinda not that good considering the manga's popularity, but you can't deny that it was a high quality adaptation even if they took a different approach of animating and directing it.
Now with Sakamoto Days, to me, personally, it's in a weird spot of being slightly below good but still above average. With each new episode it gets a bit worse and I'm not sure if it's the way it's animated/directed or I'm just not really feeling the vibe of it. I don't want to criticize it more because these days for some reason, you can't say anything bad about basically any anime or you will be considered as a hater or whatever. You either have to enjoy/appreciate eveything or just don't watch anything at all.
The CSM Situation was because of the tone adaptation sucked⊠Do you even understand why they are changing the tone completely from the movie onwards where it doesnât take itself way too seriously anymore? Do you even understand that CGI using for no reason was and still is bad? They even said âCGI is the futureâ only to get blown back and stop using it most of the time for JJKâŠ
Now Sakamoto days isnât above average with every episode it is getting worse than One punch man S2 and thatâs saying something.
Confused_100 said: The CSM Situation was because of the tone adaptation sucked Delusional to keep insisting on this two years later. Just let it go. |
Confused_100 said: ejleon said: @Confused_100 My point flew over your head. Iâm saying that animation today is far more advanced than it was, and people are spoiled, so they donât appreciate it. Yet somehow it looks worse than 2000s animations⊠Weird huh Weird? Perhaps we are not thinking of the same thing then. That would make more sense. |
ejleonMar 1, 3:47 AM
| Note: I donât lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Confused_100 said: ejleon said: @Confused_100 Do you always let everyone else decide for you what you should like or dislike? Honestly, I donât care if Iâm the only human on earth that lies a certain anime, if I enjoy, that is all that matters. No? But you are being a contrarian on purpose though lol Actually, youâre the one being contrary to what was said. Because I was agreeing with someone else above when you responded. đ |
ejleonMar 1, 3:47 AM
| Note: I donât lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
| Maybe people are desperately asking too much for the anime to be like SNK, JJK, or that mediocre anime that is DanDaDan. Now look, i'm not going to become neither some loser who don't give a damn about the animation nor will i ever become an "Animation Puritan/Expert". But do these people really believe that the animation is the only thing that matters in the anime like it's the most important aspect of the show/movie/OVA/special/whatever? Not every anime will be guaranteed that the animation will be on the same level as whatever popular anime they watch, these days. Money is tight and the Japanese cable networks can also be restricted, when it comes to the budget of the animation. Plus not every anime that does have "good" animation will turn out to be all that great. The show needs actual good writing, good story, good music and good characters to keep the anime afloat or atleast entertain the fans of the manga/light novels. After all, the writing is "The Heart" of anime, while the animation is "The Appearance/Look" of the animation. And if you don't have a good heart, then not everyone in the world's going to love you, no matter how gorgeous you look. That's the same case with me when watching DanDaDan for the first time. Yes. It has some of the most beautiful animation ever seen, but that's all the anime had to show. The rest is just plain boring with the most boring and uninteresting storytelling ever told and the characters are just as lovable as a wood plank. Flat, boring, annoying and all round just not interesting to learn, know or care about. |
| "Today's music ain't got the same soul I like that old time rock and roll" -Bob Seger in 1978. |
Reply to Leon888
@kihel You don't take into account that knowing that there is an anime that is unsatisfactory for a manga that you like when you can find many good and well animated adaptations (eg jjk, demon slayer, fire force...) still presents a strong feeling of stress and anger. The fact that some people like it does not make the anime good and manga readers are right to expect better treatment, but the fact that they made such a superficial work is really a sign of dissatisfaction and mockery, whoever allowed this should be fired.
| @Leon888 I do not need you to tell me the fact that there are unsatisfactory animations for my favorite manga, which causes me strong stress. I myself am a reader of this manga, but I did not expect better and higher quality animation for the anime being made before it was animated. I was hoping that a normal quality animation would be enough, not high quality, and that people would start reading the manga because of the anime. Nor have I ever considered what you call âDemon Slayerâ, âJJKâ, etc. to be excellent animation. Everyone has their own definition of excellent animation, and some people go out of their way to compare it to other works, while others don't. Also, if one were to say that the animation is so bad that the person who allowed it should be fired, then it would be the author of the manga who allowed it to be animated who would be the first to be fired. If you are very dissatisfied with the quality of the anime, but really want it to be improved and written better, it would be more meaningful if you had time to write comments here and direct your opinions about the points you want to see improved to the officials, and I think it is the fans of the work who can do that. Ummm...since neither your words nor what I want to convey can be translated neatly and I don't think I can write a clear sentence, there is no need for a reply. |
        |
kihel said: If you truly wanted to save or improve it, they would be sending requests to the animation studio, detailing what changes or improvements theyâd like to see. If those suggestions could improve quality without increasing costs, the studio would likely welcome them. Animation studios usually have contact sections on their websites where people can send such feedback directly. At this point, both money and manpower have already been allocated, and the company is moving forward with the second cour. If you really wants to scrap everything and have the work redone, you should try becoming a sponsor for the project. @kihei Well said, but I wonder how many so-called fans actually consider doing these kinds of thing as they apparently enjoy ranting on social media platforms rather than making an attempt to send constructive criticism to the production committee. |
| People these days are satisfied with anything, this shit is subpar and everyone who defends it should watch OPMS2 20 times a week as a punishment. People literally writing shit like "well maybe if we are nicer and we ask them to do better it will become better" LMFAOOO I will gift you a turd to y'all for Christmas and I bet most of the people who defend this shit will receive it gladly since it was a gift anyways. |
Davo-oMar 16, 3:41 PM
Reply to Bastiono
I love it when people get upset that a show isn't a 1-1 duplicate of it's source. Get over yourselves.
The show is doing exactly what it should be, and that's not to be a faithful remake, it's to get people to purchase the manga
The show is doing exactly what it should be, and that's not to be a faithful remake, it's to get people to purchase the manga
Bastiono said: I love it when people get upset that a show isn't a 1-1 duplicate of it's source If anything, a big part of the problem is that it IS too close to the source. What works in manga won't always work in anime, yet so many sequences are just taken directly from the panels but with just the bare mininum added, which creates a situation where people have no other basis but to compare directly to the manga. That is just really basic storyboarding. |
| this is exactly why i dont read manga first and watch its anime adaptation. sometimes its too much of a disappointment. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )IzanaSolos - Mar 15 |
162 |
by bryansao
»»
Yesterday, 11:59 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )anime-prime - Jan 25 |
138 |
by terebitosan
»»
Yesterday, 10:16 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )IzanaSolos - Mar 8 |
82 |
by souledge94
»»
Apr 3, 3:50 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )IzanaSolos - Mar 1 |
130 |
by souledge94
»»
Apr 3, 3:35 AM |
|
Poll: » Sakamoto Days Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Softhenic03 - Feb 22 |
100 |
by souledge94
»»
Apr 3, 3:21 AM |